Coffee Cake That Actually Contains Coffee
Why put coffee in coffee cake?
Because bitterness balances sugar. Most coffee cake is sweet on sweet, with streusel adding more sugar on top of an already sweet crumb. Coffee cuts through it the same way salt does in caramel.
Use strong brewed coffee in the batter and finely ground coffee in the streusel.
Fire Watch is the Colombian medium roast most people start with, and it works in almost anything you own.
A dark roast works best. Its chocolate notes survive baking where a light roast disappears.
| Component | Coffee form | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Batter | Strong brewed, cooled | 120 ml |
| Streusel | Finely ground | 2 tsp |
| Glaze (optional) | Strong brewed | 1 tbsp |
| Roast to use | Dark or espresso | Any of the above |
Now you know what it is. Here is whether it is worth making.
Knowing the definition is the easy half. The part that decides whether you like it is what goes in the cup underneath.
A drink built on mediocre coffee tastes like mediocre coffee with extra steps.
See the lineup →What is the method?
Standard creaming method for the batter with cooled strong coffee as part of the liquid. Rub the streusel together with ground coffee included, layer half the batter, half the streusel, then repeat.
Bake at 350F for about 40 minutes for a 9 inch square, until a skewer comes out clean.
Let it cool at least twenty minutes. The streusel needs to set or it slides.
The ratio is the recipe. The bean is the flavour.
You can follow any of these to the gram and still not enjoy it, because everything downstream of the roast is decoration.
Start with coffee you would drink black, then build on it.
Browse best sellers →Does the ground coffee in the streusel work?
Yes, in small amounts. Two teaspoons of finely ground coffee across the whole streusel adds aroma and slight bitterness without grittiness. More than that and the texture suffers.
Grind it fine, finer than you would for espresso. Coarse grounds read as grit.
Skip this step if you only have coarse pre-ground coffee.
One bag you know how to use beats five you do not.
Learn one roast properly. Then make sure you never open the cupboard and find it empty.
- Pick the roast that suits how you actually brew.
- Set it to resupply on a schedule that matches what you drink.
- Stop thinking about it. You do not hit zero again.
What should you serve it with?
A medium roast, brewed normally. Serving a dark coffee alongside a coffee-heavy cake stacks bitterness on bitterness.
This is the one case where the traditional naming is actually useful guidance.
It keeps three days in a sealed container and is better on day two.
Brew it. Get after it.
Whatever tomorrow asks of you, it goes better on a cup that was worth the effort.
Subscriptions take 30% off the first order automatically. No code, nothing to remember. One time orders take 15% with WELCOME15.
Shop the lineup →Questions people actually ask
Does coffee cake actually contain coffee?
Traditionally no. The name refers to cake served with coffee. Adding coffee to the batter and streusel is a modern improvement rather than the classic recipe.
What kind of coffee should you bake with?
A dark or espresso roast. Its chocolate notes survive baking, where the delicate fruit notes of a light roast are lost entirely.
Can you use instant coffee in baking?
Yes, and it dissolves more reliably than brewed coffee in some applications. Use less liquid to compensate if you dissolve it in a small amount of water.
Why put ground coffee in streusel?
It adds aroma and slight bitterness that balances the sugar. Grind it very fine, and keep it to about two teaspoons or the texture turns gritty.
How long does coffee cake keep?
About three days in a sealed container at room temperature, and it is generally better on the second day once the crumb settles.
